THE OSCAR PROJECT
Menu

The Oscar Project Reviews

Fantastic Planet (Laloux) 1973

1/9/2023

0 Comments

 
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links and we receive a commission if you visit a link and buy something on our recommendation. Purchasing via an affiliate link doesn’t cost you any extra and the opinions expressed in this post are the author's own. For more details see our disclosure policy and privacy policy.
Picture
I’m searching for ways that this film would be more enjoyable, and I’m sure most of the answers to that question involve copious amounts of drugs.

I received this film as a recommendation in a movie challenge I’m participating in online, and the category for the week was surrealist films, and let me tell you, Fantastic Planet definitely falls into that genre. There were times that this felt like the animated versions of picture books I remember from my youth, but dipped in a Dali painting and then rolled through a pile of the oddest rejected creature creations from Star Wars.
​
The animation in the film is basic and that’s really just fine. The creations mentioned above are truly unique and I don’t think I’ve ever seen anything like them on film or elsewhere. I really enjoyed the visual approach, and the lack of complex animation actually contributes to being able to focus on the story.

​Unfortunately, it’s the story that is a bit lacking. Like the animation, the story is very basic, but at the same time it is strongly allegorical. To summarize, the story focuses on a young Om (human) named Terr who is taken in by a Draag child on a distant planet. Terr is treated as a pet, complete with collar and silly outfits, until he eventually escapes and finds a group of Oms that he aligns himself with. The Oms learn about the Draag society from an information headset Terr brought with him and eventually rise up against the Draags.

The allegory should be pretty obvious to anyone who has ever had a pet of their own or seen kids trying to cook ants with a magnifying glass. In that respect, it feels a bit heavy handed and direct, something I wouldn’t expect from a French film. I appreciate the effort, but don’t feel like the execution was as good as it could have been.
Being a French film, I wish I could have watched this with the original French voices and English subtitles. Unfortunately, the English voice cast was bad and probably detracted from my enjoyment of the film. On the other hand, the music was terrific. It was very clearly from the 1970s, but had a good vibe to it throughout.

If you’re looking for something different from the traditional animation from Disney, Pixar, Dreamworks, etc., this is definitely one that fits that bill, but I’m not sure it’s truly a great film.

6 out of 10
0 Comments

The Abyss (Cameron) 1989

11/17/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Long before director James Cameron took us on the most famous ocean voyage of the 20th century, he embarked on an undersea adventure that taxed everyone involved, but still manages to hold up over 30 years later.
​
The Abyss (affiliate link) features a small crew of Navy SEALs traveling to a deep sea oil drilling platform with the mission of finding a nuclear submarine that crashed nearby and retrieve the warheads before the Soviets can get to them. The team is led by Cameron regular Michael Biehn playing Lieutenant Hiram Coffey. Ed Harris is in excellent form here as the platform’s foreman, Virgil "Bud" Brigman alongside Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio as Dr. Lindsey Brigman, Bud’s estranged wife and designer of the special platform.

​After recently reading a book all about Cameron’s films and learning what went into making this film, I’m not at all surprised by how well the underwater photography holds up all these years later. True, there are a few instances where it’s a bit clunky and could be done better today with digital images. But the look and feel of all the underwater scenes are generally superb, owed in large part to the insistence by Cameron that most of them be shot in an enormous tank built specifically for the film.

The other visual element that must be mentioned is the water creature that comes into the station mid-way through the film. Even if you’ve never seen the film, you probably have seen images of the water creature or heard about how difficult it was for ILM to create it. So much had been made of this sequence that I foolishly expected it to be a more central part of the film, and was quite disappointed when it only covered a few short minutes of screen time.

​What brings the whole film down just a bit is that the visual appeal doesn’t quite make up for the story that begins to break down as it passes the 2-hour mark. Like many Cameron films, The Abyss is too long and loses steam after the midway point. While we are initially led believe that Lieutenant Coffey and his team are the villain as they fight Bud and his crew for control of the rig, the true enemy in the film is the crushing depths of the ocean, and the lack of time to complete the mission.
​
The ending of the film feels a bit unearned by the rest of the story and the last five minutes of the film feel like Cameron just didn’t know how to end things and wrote “and they all lived happily ever after” on the last page of the script. The visuals and technology are a sight to behold even many years later, but all that doesn’t make up for a story that feels unfinished.

7 out of 10
0 Comments

Thor: Love and Thunder (Waititi) 2022

7/12/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Thor is back and I wish I could say better than ever, but unfortunately Love and Thunder leaves a bit to be desired.

Much was made of the return of Natalie Portman to the Thor franchise, and it was great to see her back on screen, and even better to see her don the Thor armor and wield Thor’s legendary hammer Mjolnir. But the truth of this film is that it feels like an awkward follow-up to what was an excellent previous installment in Thor: Ragnarok.

The film picks up with Thor as he tries to figure out what to do with his life after Avengers: Endgame where he left with the remaining Guardians of the Galaxy and while they figured prominently in the trailers promoting the film, I’ll disappoint any Guardians fans by letting you know they disappear about 15 minutes into the film. Don’t worry, they will be back with their holiday special on Disney+ and another theatrical film in the works, but Chris Pratt has been busy with Amazon lately, so the Guardians scenes in this film are pretty limited.

​The other high point of the film is Christian Bale’s Gorr the God Butcher. The film actually opens with his backstory and I wish we’d gotten more about his character. We quickly understand his motivations from the opening scenes of the film, but there was so much more they could have done with the character. His lines are sparse and Bale delivers them with his typical dedication to the material, but I couldn’t help hearing Bruce Wayne/Batman in some of his scenes.

The last elephant in the room has to be the Thor/Jane Foster relationship. In some ways, it’s perfectly awkward that they are working together after spending years apart. The film drops in a short flashback sequence that shows how they grew apart as each was more dedicated to their work, saving the world with science and saving the universe with a hammer. I love both Portman and Hemsworth as actors and think they are both better than some of the material they were given here, but it feels like the awkward relationship factor was turned up to 11 and quite overdone.
Thor: Love and Thunder is still a fun film. There are plenty of new characters introduced and we may look back in five years’ time with a different lens after seeing what else has transpired in the MCU, but for now this film didn’t quite reach its full potential.

6 out of 10
0 Comments

Don't Look Up (McKay) 2021

1/4/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
This is a fascinating documentary look at the crazy media obsessed culture we live in today and the immediate effects our reliance on social media has on our ability to digest and be critical of information.

Wait, this isn't a documentary? That just makes it even more depressing.

Don't Look Up is a fantastic political/social satire that gets right at the heart of the problems facing the world today. The horrible part about this film is that nearly every beat is fully believable. The pop-star going on a trendy talk show to spend 20 minutes discussing her recent public breakup followed by a short segment of the same show on a pending cataclysmic event that no one even pays attention to. Yet even as horrible as this is, it's also the genius of the film, getting us to look at this by presenting it in a way that is utterly ridiculous, but completely plausible at the same time.

This film is unique in that nearly every character has their likeable moments and their moments when you hate their guts (yes, I said nearly for a reason). The cast is stellar from top to bottom including the likes of Jennifer Lawrence and Leonardo DiCaprio, Cate Blanchett, Meryl Streep, Timothée Chalamet, and Jonah Hill. It's also nice to see several of these actors playing somewhat against their standard roles. Streep plays the ruthless president, more interested in her party winning the midterm elections than the end of the world. Even Chalamet sheds the meek young man and shows up in the final act as a grungy kid from the street stealing booze from the liquor store.

My only qualm with the acting actually comes from DiCaprio's character, but it's more the script or the direction than Leo's fault. His portrayal of Dr. Randall Mindy at the beginning and end of the film is spot on, but he spends the middle third of the film in what seems like a different character that was cut from the script and blended into Dr. Mindy.

That small qualm aside, the film made me laugh out loud, ponder my own technology usage, and wonder to myself how much of what we see on the screen actually goes on behind closed doors, or possibly even right out in the open, without most people even noticing. The film is a wake up call of sorts for me and one that will stick with me for some time to come.

9 out of 10

0 Comments

    Archives

    October 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    January 2022
    July 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    March 2020
    September 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019

    Categories

    All
    Action/Adventure
    Animation
    Based On Books
    Basketball
    Best Adapted Screenplay
    Best Cinematography
    Best Director
    Best Film Editing
    Best Original Song
    Best Picture
    Best Sound Editing
    Best Sound Mixing
    Best Visual Effects
    Biography
    Comedy
    Crime
    Disney
    Disney+
    Documentary
    Drama
    Family
    Fantasy
    Films About Films
    Halloween
    History
    Horror
    Marvel
    MCU
    Music
    Musical
    Mystery
    Netflix
    Oscar Nominee
    Oscar Winner
    Pixar
    Science Fiction
    Short Film
    SparkShort
    Sports
    Thriller
    War Films
    Western

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • Jonathan Ytreberg
    • KritPick
    • Sean
    • Yan Wong
  • The Oscar Project Podcast
  • Film Podcasts
  • About
  • Contact
  • Oscar Nominee Tracker
  • Policies & Disclosures
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • Jonathan Ytreberg
    • KritPick
    • Sean
    • Yan Wong
  • The Oscar Project Podcast
  • Film Podcasts
  • About
  • Contact
  • Oscar Nominee Tracker
  • Policies & Disclosures